The city of Longmeadow, Massachusetts has failed to get a two-thirds voting majority necessary to move forward with its plan to deploy affordable fiber to every city resident.

The vote comes after local telecom monopolies were caught funding an out of town dark money nonprofit to sow doubt about the benefits of the project in the minds of the local electorate.

Longmeadow officials were exploring whether to take out an $8.6 million loan for the initial phase of the $27 million fiber project, paid for by a property tax increase of $97 per year. 

The city is just the latest Western Massachusetts municipality to explore the option after decades of dissatisfaction with regional monopolies Comcast and Verizon.

The $8.6 billion would have financed a central fiber hub, an initial pilot area, and a second construction phase expected to connect around 1,600 homes and about 50 businesses and multi-dwelling units (MDUs). The network would have been run by the city as a utility.

Ben Brown, a member of the original Longmeadow Municipal Fiber Task Force, had pushed the network’s potential benefits before the vote.

“With town-owned fiber, you actually get what you pay for,” Brown said. “Speed that doesn’t slow down at peak hours, reliability that doesn’t drop when it rains, pricing that’s transparent, no promotional rates that quietly double after a year, no random fees, no surprises on your bill … the fiber we put in the ground today, is the same fiber that will carry whatever speed comes next.”